Darkness Falls (2003)
Written by John Fasano, James Vanderbilt and Joe Harris / Directed by Jonathan Liebesman
Starring Chaney Kley, Emma Caulfield and Lee Cormie
85 mins / Revolution Studios / Rated PG-13
Retail: $19.95 / Street: $17

by Alex Mestas 5/28/2004
More info: Amazon
Darkness Falls DVD Cover
The Cover
Add this to the short list of things that creep me out: sepia-toned pictures of children from the mid 20th century....eww...do they all have to stare like that? At least the snot nosed brats smile in this day and age. That's how Darkness Falls starts. And I have to say I like the setup. As the legend goes, because of an overly involved back-story and front loaded narrative, on the night you lose your last tooth in Darkness Falls, the Tooth Fairy will come and visit. If you gaze into her horrible visage then you will die or something. I'm not quite sure, because the movie isn't entirely clear on actually execution of the ghost's plan. The Tooth Fairy was supposed to be the next big thing in horror, but Darkness Falls was a universal disappointment both commercially and critically. Instead of writing an actual review like I should, here are the notes I took:

-The soundtrack is lush and wet, pulsing in that creepy way that only horror movies can.

-Hey! It's the creepy kid from The Ring again! No, wait. It's just a similar looking moppet. And here's another idea: quit making all the goddamn kids the beckoners of doom who seem to speak from beyond.

-The writing is stilted an expositional. Hasn't anyone heard of subtlety in this place? It took three people to write this?

-Why is it that the Tooth Fairy is attacking people that haven't seen her? Oh well. But it's huge lapses like this that make the whole thing distracting and un-scary.

-Par for the course: a wussy rock soundtrack - think I Know What You Did Last Summer, Scream, etc.

-The camerawork is pretty lush and full - reminiscent of the world's whoriest director, Michael Bay. I may not always like the man's movies, but he sure knows how to pick cinematographers. Same goes here.

-The usual jump scares courtesy of the soundtrack. Enough with that junk all ready. It's boring.

-Uh-oh the kids are pale and they speak with accents. OHHHHHH CAAAAAANNNAAADDDAAAA!

-Here's something else creepy. Fourteen year olds who speak and emote like adults. These young kids have better relationships than I do.

Those are my actual, typed notes. I'm not kidding. As for Darkness Falls, I've seen far worse. I think my lack of interest is that I can't swing one way or the other. I don't like it but I don't hate it as much as Bad Company. Emma Caulfield is great, but I didn’t recognize her immediately in this role. She lost her Buffy vibrancy when she showed up screen here. Darkness Falls is fine for a group of sorority girls who like wine coolers, but if you're looking for another Exorcist or even The Ring, you won't find it here.

Movie Grade: C-

Video: 2 out of 5
The good: The movie comes in two flavors, widescreen and full on the same side. This usually means that the video quality suffers. On the widescreen (which isn't anamorphic), through the black bars you can see the ghosted images of the full screen version at times. This is annoying. It also means that the full screen version isn't cropped from the widescreen - it's called "open frame" and there's a good chance you might see a boom mic peeking into the top of the frame at some point. I didn't see anything, but I wasn't looking that hard.
Widescreen 2.35:1 and Full Screen 1.33:1

Emma Caulfield in Darkness Falls
Figured you'd like a sexy picture of Emma, rather than a frame from the movie.

Audio: 4 out of 5
The audio is actually quite nice on this disc. The atmosphere of the soundtrack is quite strong and it's weezy and wet, perfect for a horror movie.
English (Dolby 5.1 and 2.0)

Extras: 3.5 out of 5
There's actually one extra that I liked. It's a ten minute tale of the "real life Tooth Fairy" and the inspiration for the movie. Nice and creepy. There's a 20 minute behind the scenes that's nothing more than film clips and annoying Australian people. There's two commentaries in which the unaccomplished director speaks about his flick and a writer explains why his dialogue is so stilted and unnatural. Ok, he doesn't. But I sure wish he would.

Overall: 2.5 out of 5
There's really no reason to outright purchase it, unless you are collecting the cumulative work of Emma Caulfield. And as for rental, well it's short, so that's good. Rent if you're doing a weekend contemporary horror film festival. Then laugh, laugh, laugh the night away and enjoy the last line of this fine movie: "I see you, bitch!"

© 2005 Lights Out Films / E-Mail Alex /